Our communities are increasingly made up of diverse groups that have diverse interests and obtain information in different ways. A rapidly changing world means that traditional approaches for gathering feedback may be less effective today. Busy schedules mean that citizens will appreciate convenient, comfortable, and quick ways to stay informed about government services and community issues, and also to register their views on them. Technology offers new opportunities for quick and cost-effective ways to distribute information, as well as reaching out and involving citizens. New variations on public meetings and other improved outreach tools can allow a more thorough vetting of issues and exchange of information that results in more widely embraced plans and projects.
Local governments will have different communication needs and a varying need for citizen comment or involvement depending on the particular type of situation. At times, local governments will simply want to get information to citizens about a new service or program, an upcoming event, important issues, or a temporary service disruption. At other times, communities may want to gather information or opinions from citizens, or even recruit citizens to study issues in depth and provide advice. At other times, it will be desirable to work directly with the public and even partner with citizens to develop alternatives, creative ideas, and solutions to community-wide concerns.
There have been several interesting efforts to categorize a "spectrum" of participation levels and to develop matrices that can be helpful in considering which type of participation technique is best fitted for specific participation needs and specific situations. Probably the first and still one of the best frameworks is the IAP2's Public Participation Toolbox prepared by the International Association for Public Participation. The National Coalition for Dialogue and Deliberation built on this framework to develop its Engagement Streams spectrum and tools matrices with increased emphasis on techniques involving higher levels of engagement. Finally, a draft Portland (OR) Public Involvement Tool Kit (Public Participation Spectrum, and Public Involvement Tools by Category) is a useful local government-developed aid for choosing the right tool for the right participation need.
The most effective community involvement programs use a combination of approaches to reach a wide cross section of the community. This Page highlights some of our favorite ideas for getting the word out, for obtaining public feedback and for involving citizens in shaping the plans and programs that significantly affect their lives.
Public Meeting Formats that Facilitate Public Participation
Public hearings are required in many situations and assure, at a minimum, the rights of interested citizens to attend and/or testify. Even so, formal city hall and courthouse settings can be intimidating, and hearings can sometimes be dominated by those who are more comfortable with public speaking. Such hearings may not be the best way to encourage comment from a wide cross-section of community residents and may not fit into citizens' busy schedules. The format of hearings often leaves little, if any, room for reasonable discussion, give or take, or response to prior testimony. Instead, it is important to conduct a thoughtful public process in advance of the public hearing. Local governments are trying new approaches to meeting with citizens and make it easier for citizens to express their opinions and for local officials to understand citizen needs. Scheduling convenient times and providing comfortable settings encourages participation. Opportunities for face-to-face exchanges can facilitate understanding and a balancing of diverse interests.
This section highlights a number of meeting approaches to supplement required hearings that can be tailored to fit a variety of situations. A combination of these approaches can generate a better understanding of issues, attract a wider spectrum of participation, and involve citizens in shaping better decisions for the community as a whole.
Open Houses, Workshops, and Forums
- Jefferson County Open House Series and Road Show to update citizens on Shoreline Master Plan progress, 03/2007 - Impressive series of community outreach meetings around the county. Each drop-in open house event featured poster displays, a repeating slideshow, an interactive digital mapping station, and a comment form. Earlier road show meetings included audience participation activities.
- Mountlake Terrace Town Center Planning Gets Citizen Involvement Award - Mountlake Terrace is the winner of a Citizen Involvement Award from the Washington State Chapter of the American Planning Association to recognize the City's Town Center multi-pronged planning and citizen involvement process. The process included neighborhood roundtables, a developer forum, 3 design workshops and 3 open houses in addition to public hearings.
- Planning Public Forums: Questions to Guide Local Officials, Terry Amsler, Institute for Local Government, 2007 - Useful questions to ask and design considerations for deciding what type of forum will best provide feedback and information that decision-makers need.
- Redmond Overlake Design Charrette, 05/06/2006 - Two-day workshop utilized visual preference survey, map exercises, developer forum, and small group roundtables to develop a preliminary concept plan for an urban center.
- Redmond Involvement. See Livable Redmond Final Report: Redmond Livable Redmond: A Community Conversation about Sustainability, 11/03/2010 - The widely publicized Livable Redmond Event included an open house with displays, keynote speaker, dinner buffet, small group discussions, and a wrap-up session.
Focus Groups/Small Group Processes
Focus group meetings provide particularly fertile ground for understanding the unique needs and interests of various community or business groups. They are designed to get at the unique perspectives/opinions of specific groups, to benefit from the groups' shared knowledge, and to understand how various groups would be affected by programs or policies. Participants are selected based on what they share in common. Other types of small group approaches may involve a broader cross-section of members. They generally encourage free expression and interaction. The back-and-forth exchange of information can lead to a creative combining of ideas and balancing of interests to refine alternatives or create entirely new solutions. Some communities break a larger audience into small "roundtable" discussion groups to focus on specific issues following a presentation to the entire audience. In either approach, the small group setting offers a more comfortable setting for speaking freely, listening, and interacting to others.
Focus Group Articles
- Can You Call It a Focus Group?, Methodology Brief, Iowa State University Extension, 05/2004 - Useful brief on distinguishing features between focus and other small groups, uses and inappropriate uses of focus groups
- Federal Highway Administration Public Involvement Techniques for Transportation Decision-Making: Small Group Discussion Techniques - Very useful, brief overview of a variety of small group discussion techniques and their uses
- Focus Groups: A Guide to Learning the Needs of Those We Serve, Office of Quality Improvement, University of Wisconsin - Madison, 2007 - Brief and useful guide about interviewing "customers" in groups to get in-depth information about their needs. The groups are generally groups with different interests and needs such as neighborhood residents, business community, developer, and others.
Focus Group Examples
- Boulder, CO Community Sustainability - Meetings-in-a-Box - Community Dialog - Summary Report, 01/2008 - The city supplemented a more broadly distributed survey by creating a hosted meeting process designed to reach underrepresented populations. See especially Introduction: Project Background. See also Community Dialog Meetings-in-a-Box Appendices - Includes meetings-in-a-box materials and discussion guide, and verbatim responses
- Olympia Solid Waste Focus Group Summary, 08/2006 - Olympia devised a particularly fruitful application of this technique. The city convened three focus groups consisting of representatives from three different industrial sectors with different types of waste streams (food, paper, and construction waste) to examine business waste generation and recycling practices and the challenges and possible strategies for reducing waste.
- Sammamish Community Center Focus Group Research Executive Summary, 06/2011 - Presents results from small group process on community center with clearly defined objectives
- Spokane Meeting in a Box, June-July, 1996 - The ultimate in comfort and convenience - a unique, and award-winning self-guided growth management plan workshop designed to be held in living rooms, community clubs or whenever and wherever convenient! Still a great outreach idea!
- University Place Resident Focus Group 2011 Report, 04/24/2011 - Professionally designed small group process to gather citizen perceptions on University Place and gather feedback for developing an effective city performance measurement and communication program. Includes meeting materials.
Task Force/Advisory Committees for Specific Plans or Issues
Citizen advisory committees are appointed to study and provide comments and advice on a (sometimes ongoing) program, project or set of issues. Members meet regularly to provide ongoing input and advice over the duration of the project. They may represent a cross-section of the community, or may be a set of people with knowledge or concerns about a particular issue. A task force is similar in some respects, but is assigned a specific task, often with a time limit for reaching a conclusion and resolving a difficult issue, subject to ratification by official decision-makers. Task forces are sometimes rather large groups in an effort to include representation from a variety of affected interest groups. The task force is often charged to work toward consensus.
- Issaquah Task Force - Klahanie Study - City appointed an annexation area advisory task force to advise the city on its annexation study, and on effective communication to the public about the study and proposed annexation
- Kent Citizen’s Task Force - Citizens provide community perspectives and advise city council on a transportation master plan
Making Meetings Fun
- Orton Family Foundation
- Community PlanIt - This online, interactive game, built by Emerson Professor Eric Gordon, brings people together over the course of several weeks to complete planning-themed missions. Players walk away with a better understanding of planning, more interest and capacity to change their communities, and great ideas for their communities.
- Photography Contests - Photography contests invite submissions from residents for photography on a certain topic — usually character of community or special places. Generally disposable cameras are distributed to participants. The sponsoring jurisdiction can offer prizes for best/most popular series, but the main objective is to stimulate interest, ideas and broader attendance, particularly for efforts like community visioning.
- Renton Benson Hill Community Plan (See Part 2 – Public Engagement) - After some initial unsuccessful efforts to grab attention, the city achieved success by piggybacking on neighborhood events, such as picnics, and mixing in some fun with the community plan outreach. A particularly successful mobile workshop was combined with a Moonlight Movie night event that was cross-promoted with the community plan outreach effort. Also see Benson Hill interactive website.
- Snoqualmie Town Hall Encore at Cascade View Elementary June 30, News Release, 06/14/2010 - Root Beer Floats are part of the attraction!
Outreach for Diverse Representation at Meetings
- Multnomah County, OR - County offers 90-minute brown bag Diversity Outreach Workshops to train staff in creatively expanding outreach to cultural and minority communities. Government and community organizations share outreach experiences, strategies, tools and tips, and evaluate current outreach effectiveness.
- Seattle Neighborhood Planning Outreach and Engagement, Governor's 2010 Smart Vision Award - Seattle's planning outreach program (engaging over 6,000 people) included use of bilingual or bicultural liaisons to host and facilitate workshops in its ethnically diverse and historically underrepresented neighborhoods.
Hand-held polling devices or "pulse pads" allow citizens to register their opinions and see the instantly tabulated responses of all participants. It is easy for any participant to register an opinion, without being in the spotlight. As one city official noted, in an AWC brief: "It seemed to defuse the very vocal minority in the audience." The polling device can feel empowering and add an element of fun. It is a better tool for gauging reaction to various alternatives or choices, rather than eliciting suggesed changes. Even so, it can provide useful feedback on specific questions and can be combined with other exercises.
- Keeping In Touch: Take the Pulse of Your Community, AWC - Using individual keypads, audience participants can respond to questions, rank priorities and see automatically tabulated answers displayed immediately in PowerPoint format.
- Marysville Special Meeting to review downtown and waterfront revitalization - Participants were invited to use pulse pads to register their priorities for short- and long-term revitalizations needs.
- Sequim Citizens help to shape Sequim 120, Mathew Nash, Sequim Gazette, March 14, 2012 - Sequim conducted a visioning open house and equipped participants with pulse pads to provide instant response to a 53 question survey. The pulse pad polling supplemented a variety of interactive activities including futures mapping exercises; a take-home "word cloud" questionnaire; and an activity focused on transportation values/priorities.
Telephone Town Hall
The telephone town hall (TTH) technology allows a city or county to efficiently call tens of thousands of residents to invite them to participate in a call-in meeting. The TTH technology can connect people from all corners of the community to the public meeting, so, it's a particularly useful way to hear from a cross section of the community on issues that affect people throughout the community. It makes it easier to hear from those who don't always speak up, since all have equal opportunity to speak without the glare of a spotlight. Although there won't be time for everyone to speak, and there isn't much opportunity for give and take, all who call in may leave a comment, and receive a reply later. It's also common to intersperse some polling questions to get a response from all listeners on some important questions.
- Telephone Town Halls Gain Popularity, Brian Tumulty, USA Today, March 7, 2012 - Telephone town halls use technology that allows vendors to call tens of thousands of people in minutes. Over the course of an hour-long telephone town hall, hundreds of thousands of calls can be placed, inviting people to listen in on a live discussion and ask questions. The format allows for prescreening of questions. And it's a convenient way to reach thousands of people instead of the dozens who might show up at a municipal building. Used by Obama administration, members of Congress, AARP, American Lung Association.
- Longmont, CO
- Fort Lauderdale, FL - Telephone Town Hall Meetings - The city employed a multi-pronged outreach program to engage citizens in a visioning process including a telephone town hall with over 41,000 participants
Videoconferencing, webinars and other technological tools allow citizens to attend and even participate in meetings without leaving home.
Charrettes bring together citizen and stakeholder groups with a team design professionals and other experts in intense, creative work sessions over a short time period. They can kick start a planning or design process and lay the foundation for the ultimate plan or project design. Ideally, charrettes provide a climate that stimulates an exchange of ideas, information, and opinions about needs and solutions. The process promotes consensus-building toward a common vision. The process harnesses the talents and energy of design professionals (as well as citizen participants) to help participants visualize alternatives and to recommend design solutions.
Charrette Articles and Resources
- An Introduction to Charrettes, Bill Lennertz and Aarin Lutzenhiser, Planning Commissioner's Journal, Summer 2008 - Nice overview
- Charrette Center - Includes definition, case studies, explanation of charrette process, and visualization tools
- National Charrette Institute - Offers Webinar and in-house training sessions, and other training resources
- The Charrette as an Agent for Change, article by Bill Lennertz, for New Urbanism: Comprehensive Report & Best Practices Guide, 3rd Ed., 2003 - Provides brief, useful description, including nine principles
- What is a Charrette?, National Charrette Institute - Three minute You-Tube video defining charrettes and describing their use. Also video of a charrette in process
- American Institute of Architects (AIA) Design Assistance Team Planning Processes
- Longview SDAT Program, Integrating SmartGrowth and LID into the City of Longview's Municipal Code, and Longview Final Report, American Institute of Architects, The Sustainable Design Assessment Team (SDAT), 2006 - Charrette focused on downtown strategies for low impact low-impact stormwater design, multimodal transportation connections, affordable housing, and code enforcement
- Port Angeles Downtown Port Angeles and The Gateway Corridor: Reconnecting to the Community: A Sustainable Design Assessment Team Final Report, 03/2009 - Design team and charrette focused on helping the city improve the vitality of downtown and the gateway corridor
- Roslyn Urban Forest Design Charrette, 2011 – The city partnered with several organizations and professional associations to conduct a charrette to move the city forward on a comprehensive trails and recreation plan and program.
- Redmond Stakeholder Charrette Summary, 152nd Avenue NE Corridor Study – Attendees refine, evaluate and then use criteria to rate alignment alternatives in a light rail transit-served corridor
This section offers articles with information and helpful tips for the effective planning and running of public meetings and hearings, meeting facilitation, and dealing with emotions and conflict at public meetings.
- Getting the Most out of Public Hearings: Ideas to Improve Public Involvement, Institute for Local Government, 2005 - This excellent pamphlet provides practical ideas for making public hearings more effective forums for participants and public officials alike - more inclusive, more informed participants and better results.
- Holding Effective Public Meetings, PlannersWeb, 10/2014 – Very useful article on effective public meetings with tips drawn from a survey of planning commission members and staff
- Be a "Meeting Hero" - A Guide to Conducting Better Meetings, Kevin Richie, Alaska Municipal League - Although older, this brief guide offers many insightful tips about getting the most out of meetings.
- Effective Meeting Facilitation: The Sine Qua Non of Planning, by Miranda Duncan, National Endowment for the Arts, 12/07/2005 - This brief guide offers particularly thoughtful tips about planning and running a meeting from start to finish.
- Group Facilitation Primer, Tree Bressen - Very useful and clear discussion of roles, guiding principles, methods, and dealing with conflicts
- Office of Quality Improvement, University of Wisconsin-Madison
- How to Lead Effective Meetings, edited by Nancy Thayer-Hart - Brief, but very useful articles, tools and templates, best practices,and meeting problem help, 2007
- "How To" Guides - Helpful information on topics of interest is presented in concise, non-technical terms in this series of papers written by Office of Quality Improvement staff.
- Facilitator Toolkit: A Guide for Helping Groups Get Results - A comprehensive guide about facilitation including the role of facilitation, group dynamics, useful techniques and decision-making tools, 09/2007
- Meetings and More, Planning Commissioners Journal - Series of excellent articles on successful public meetings (Available through MRSC library loan or for purchase from Planner's Web)
Dealing with Emotions and Conflict at Public Meetings
- Addressing Disruptions at Public Meetings, Ramsey Ramerman, Assistant City Attorney, City of Everett, Open Government Advisor, MRSC, April 2012 - Reviews some of the procedural hoops and liability risks associated with remedies for addressing disruptions at public meetings -
- Fostering Dialogue Across Divides: A Nuts and Bolts Guide from the Public Conversations Project, Maggie Herzig and Laura Chasin, Public Conversations Project, 2006 - A comprehensive guide to conducting successful dialogues on the most heated topics. Includes thoughtful tips on listening, well crafted questions, session design, emotional readiness, and facilitation.
- Meeting Great Expectations: Dealing With Emotional Audiences, Western City Magazine, October 2009
- Responding to Emotions and Conflicts in Public Hearings, Institute for Local Government
Guides to Help Citizens Participate Effectively in Meetings
Speakers Bureaus, Presentations to Existing Groups, and Tours
A number of communities have established speakers bureaus with staff, or other effective speakers, that are available to make presentations on local government programs or topics. Since many service organizations, school classrooms, and other community organizations need short programs or speakers on a regular basis, it is a great opportunity for local jurisdictions to get the word out about some great services and programs, emerging issues, or to discuss plans on the horizon. It is also a great way to stay connected with the community in a positive way, and often, to learn of interests or concerns of the community groups. Guided or self-guided tours are also an excellent way to increase citizen understanding of important government services and to show off examples of quality development.
- Hernando County, FL Speakers Bureau - Local organizations may choose from a long list of prepared topics presented by county staff or may request a speaker on another topic of interest
- Richland - Speakers' Bureau - City staff available to speak to community groups or schools on a variety of topics by appointment. Tours of a number of city facilities also available
- Snoqualmie City Hosts Speakers Forum: Planning a Green Future, 02/02/2010 - One of a series of free sustainability speakers forums
- Fort Collins, CO Fort Collins Plan Van - A set of van tours highlighted various projects including recent urban design winners, 1950s neighborhoods, Mountain Vista Subarea, ghost signs, South College Corridor Plan, and the evolution of neighborhood planning. Although this award-winning approach is longer offered for budgetary reasons, the city encourages self-guided tours of these examples
- Spokane Infill Housing Self-Guided Tour - A collection of local examples to demonstrate how well-designed infill projects can fit different types of areas.
- Sammamish The Town Center Bus Rolls Again, City Views @ (Newsletter), 2006, p. 4 - Bus tour of neighboring cities helped citizen committee members visualize town center types and city design issues
- Cowlitz-Wahkiakum Council of Governments Cowlitz South Loop Trail Tour of the Proposed South Cowlitz River Trail Loop, YouTube via Google Maps
Newsletters, Columns, and Flyers
Citizen surveys have frequently been used to gather citizen feedback and gauge public opinion. As these articles and examples illustrate, it is essential to assure a representative sample and careful study design to obtain meaningful results.
- Bellingham Opinion Surveying - Biennial service priorities and citizen satisfaction surveys
- Bainbridge Island The National Citizen Survey: City of Bainbridge Island, WA 2011 - Collaboration between the International City Managers Association (ICMA) and the National Research Center to assess community and services strengths and weaknesses in eight dimensions: community quality, community design, public safety, environmental sustainability, recreation and wellness, community inclusiveness, civic engagement, and public trust
- Redmond Citizen Surveys - Questions cover quality of life, top issues, satisfaction with services, city government communications, plan for the future and service priorities
- Sammamish Parks, Recreation, & Open Space (PRO) Plan Preliminary Survey Results, 07/20/2012 - Questions to provide information to guide development of six-year park, recreation and open space plan and potential development of aquatic center, including preferences regarding programs and facilities, willingness to walk, and others
- Spokane Valley Community Preference Survey, 2004 - Although it is not current, this is a good example of a survey that gathered representative community input on a variety of future growth and development-related issues.
- Vancouver 2012 Direction Finder Survey - Surveys satisfaction with government services, livability factors, and community priorities.
Online Citizen Surveys
Online surveys on websites allow citizens to communicate with city hall or other city departments, provide a way for local governments to get feedback, and give citizens a way to submit comments about specific policies and plans. Here are a few examples of online surveys being conducted by Washington cities and counties.
The Visual Preference Survey (VPS) was developed by architect Anton Nelessen and is an effective tool for educating and involving community members in land use planning. The process involves members of the community in ranking images of a community or region, including photographs of streets, houses, stores, office buildings, parks, open space, and other key civic features. The tool helps citizens to visualize, compare and react to various design treatments, which is a difficult topic to communicate in words. The results of the VPS are particularly useful in developing comprehensive plans, redevelopment plans, and other plans and projects that relate to future development.
Community Image/Visual Preference Surveys
- Bellevue Eastgate/I-90 Land Use and Transportation Project Visual Preference Survey Summary Report, 06/2011 - Shows image rated most and least desirable for various land use categories, signage, parking, trails and other elements
- Clark County Synopsis of Public Comments, Highway 99 Subarea Plan Visual Preference Survey
- Martha's Vineyard, MA Visual Preference Survey, 12/2005 - This survey was structured in a unique way with 20 Vineyarders given disposable cameras to take photos of images that responded to questions about visual character. Then a sampling of the photos were used in a larger survey of both permanent residents and seasonal visitors to gauge preferences.
- Mukilteo Downtown Business District Subarea Plan Visual Preference Survey, Results Summary, 07/01/2008
- Sammamish Town Center Signage: Visual Preference Survey, 02/19/2009 - Objective is to promote signage that contributes to the desired character of the Town Center, and to consider appropriate signage citywide
Reaching Citizens through Technology
Local Government Education for Youth
- Alachua County, FL Civic Education Series - The program is designed to explain and clarify the complex nature of County government and to show citizens how their tax dollars are spent. The goal in this effort is to foster an informed citizenry. Ambitious agenda, although daytime hours may limit who can attend.
- Planning Academy I for Neighborhoods - Multiday workshop with presentations, hands on exercises, and homework assignments to facilitate understanding of planning, land use issues, and regulation, and to develop skills for effectively participating in the process
- Planning Academy II: Green Bellingham - Achieving Infill, Enhancing Character - Explores alternative housing types that may be integrated into appropriate areas of existing and new neighborhoods
- Citizen Academies, Citizens Police Academies, MRSC
- Citizen Academies, University of North Carolina School of Government - Clearinghouse of information on citizens' academies, information, and innovative practices culled from dozens of successful programs across the country.
- Planning Association of Washington and Washington State Department of Commerce
- The Short Course on Local Planning - Three-hour workshop which covers the legal basis for planning in Washington, comprehensive plan and development regulation basics, and role of the planning commission. Includes videos on a variety of planning topics
- Land Use Boot Camp - Basic Training, 02/29/2012 Agenda - More intensive workshop designed for cadet elected and appointed officials, planning professionals or those seeking a refresher in core planning essentials on legal issues and processes encountered in local land use permitting.