skip navigation

No Magic Homelessness Bullet


June 4, 2018 by Lynn Nordby
Category: Homelessness

No Magic Homelessness Bullet

“There’s no magic bullet or one size fits all solution to homelessness,” Seattle Mayor Jenny Durkan said recently. Solutions need to be as varied as the people and causes of homelessness. The needs of a homeless teen, kicked out of their home or leaving the foster care system, differ from those of a veteran with PTSD, someone with a mental health disorder or substance addiction, or a family with children.

Creative ideas for meeting these varied needs are appearing steadily. Whether they’re intended for emergency, temporary, or permanent habitation is up in the air, as are some of the ideas. Let’s just say they range from the ridiculous to the sublime. What follows are some examples from all over the map.

These Tiny Houses for the Homeless Perch on Building Walls

This article profiles Norwegian architect Andreas Tjeldflaat envisions a honeycomb of stackable or suspended 3D-printed living pods up against the side of a building, perhaps overlooking a parking lot where individuals could sleep in secure private quarters and share a communal area for cooking, bathing, etc. Such structures could be quickly and inexpensively built and relocated as needed.

Housing for the Homeless: 14 Smart & Sensitive Solutions

This article describes ideas ranging from folding sleep capsules inspired by origami to tiny living units the size of a large kitchen island to prefabricated stackable modular units that could be relatively permanent. Clearly some of these ideas would only be suitable for temporary occupancy or simply to protect the occupant from the weather while others could be a rapid solution to providing more permanent, long-term housing.

Could 3D-printed houses help solve the homelessness problem?

This pilot project can reportedly create a small house in 24 hours with a concrete mixture, using a 3D-printing technique. The unit cost is estimated at $10,000 and expected to be as little as $4,000 eventually. While the article seems to describe these as potential projects for the developing world, it doesn’t take much imagination to see this as a practical application anywhere. Speed, affordability, and durability appear to be strong elements favoring this idea.

How to Build a Conestoga Hut

This inexpensive shelter design is promoted by Community Supported Shelters (CSS), an Oregon nonprofit, as an alternative to “tent cities.” CSS envisions villages made of these small buildings that have been specially adapted for sleeping.

The Conestoga hut design allows for very rapid construction by those with little or no building experience and includes a lockable door for better security and protection from the elements. The City of Walla Walla was just recognized with a 2018 Municipal Excellence Award by the Association of Washington Cities for responding to a particularly harsh winter by building 31 “Conestoga huts” for the homeless. These insulated, weatherproof huts were built in cooperation with a local housing group.

L.A.’s first shipping container complex for the homeless is on the way

If you’ve stumbled across any of the cable television channels devoted to what one friend described as “real estate porn,” you’ve no doubt seen a segment devoted to repurposing shipping containers. One side effect of world trade is the abundance of these sturdy steel boxes, which are available from coast to coast. They can be adapted into an efficient tiny home or joined together to create a variety of configurations, from the frugal to the extravagant.

This article describes a project in California where a number of them are being transformed into a multi-unit housing project for the homeless. A ready-to-occupy unit can now even be ordered from Amazon. Is your Prime membership up to date?

Community Voices: Your Ideas for Addressing Homelessness

The San Francisco Public Press asked its readers to contribute ideas for dealing with homeless people in their community. Ideas ranged from providing better services to the homeless in different environments to allowing the homeless to occupy vacant buildings. The piece ended with a lament from a long time resident indicating he was simply fed up with the city's problems and wanted to move away.

The Delancey Street Foundation

Finally, also from San Francisco, this is perhaps the sublime element of the whole blog post. A passionate advocate for people in need, Mimi Silbert began a self-help program that now has a nearly 50-year track record of working with populations that are most at-risk of becoming homeless. As described at the Delancey Street Foundation's website, this includes:

…substance abusers, ex-convicts, homeless, and others who have hit bottom. Our average resident has been a hard-core drug addict for 16 years, abusing alcohol and multiple drugs, has dropped out of school at the 7th grade, and has been institutionalized several times.

This program takes people that would be considered to have no future and teaches them skills and responsibility with “no staff, no government funding, and no professionals…developing a model of social entrepreneurship, of education, of rehabilitation”.

The Delancey Street Foundation has grown beyond San Francisco's border and now operates facilities in Los Angeles, New Mexico, North Carolina, South Carolina, New York, and Massachusetts.

Reflecting back to Mayor Durkan’s comment, perhaps the Delancey Street program exemplifies the nature of the problem as well as the solution. There is no simple, quick fix to homelessness. It will take hard work on the part of advocates, community leaders, activists, taxpayers, and the homeless themselves to make any substantive progress.

Questions? Comments

If you have questions about this or other local government issues, please use our Ask MRSC form or call us at (206) 625-1300 or (800) 933-6772. If you have comments about this blog post, please comment below or email me at lnordby@mrsc.org.

About Lynn Nordby

Lynn’s public sector career includes 30 years in local government management and experience in virtually all municipal services including the operations of a wide variety of municipal utilities. He is a Credentialed Manager through the ICMA Voluntary Credentialing program.

VIEW ALL POSTS BY Lynn Nordby

Leave a Comment

* Required field

Security code

Comments

"We can't just build our way out of this. The forms of housing mentioned are suitable as short-term solutions, but Delancey has the better idea, going after the root problems. People have long-term, personal issues. Let's teach and/or treat the people who can be helped that way."

Glenn Peterson on Jun 19, 2018 6:24 PM

"The "honeycomb pods" idea is still in a conceptual stage so I'm sure there would be details such as safety and security that would still need to be incorporated into a workable design. From the article though it does appear that the exterior facing clear wall would be solid"

Lynn Nordby on Jun 7, 2018 1:43 PM

"I have to disagree with Ms. Durkan. We have laws that are not being enforced. The volume of used syringes in public spaces is staggering, and shocking. Start with public safety as a focus. Also, the honeycomb 'pods' are intriguing, but how would someone be prevented from falling or jumping off?"

guest on Jun 7, 2018 12:58 PM

3 comments on No Magic Homelessness Bullet

 more

Blog Archives

GO

Follow Our Blog