skip navigation

When Values Collide: Finding a Path Forward

Early in my career, I thought conflict meant people disagreeing about a specific issue. If we, as leaders, could gather enough information, explain the options clearly enough, and make a strong recommendation, surely the issue could be resolved and the group could move on.

I learned otherwise during a debate over the future of a downtown.

As part of the debate, the community was considering whether to allow more multi-family housing in and around its historic downtown. Some debate participant worried greater density would change the character and identity of a place they cared deeply about. Others believed the community needed additional housing, investment, and opportunities for future generations.

The disagreement was about zoning, but something deeper was driving it. What I discovered is: Conflict is often friction around competing values.

One group wanted to preserve history, identity, and community character. Another valued housing, economic vitality, and preparing for the future.

Both cared deeply about the community. They simply valued different things about it.

Look Beneath the Position

Leaders often try to resolve conflict at the level where it presents itself, such as:

  • Should we increase density or not?
  • Build the project or not?
  • Spend money on this priority or that one?

However, those are positions. The values underneath them are often more revealing.

Over time, I learned to spend less time asking, “Who is right?,” and more time asking, “What value is each person trying to protect?”

That question does not make disagreement disappear, but it can change the conversation:

  • Someone opposing development may not simply be 'against growth'. They may be trying to preserve a sense of place.
  • Someone advocating for development may be concerned about housing opportunities or the community’s economic future.

Understanding those motivations gives leaders a different starting point. People can disagree with the solution while acknowledging both sides are trying to protect something they value.

Find a Path Between Competing Values

In this case I mentioned above, the city council ultimately allowed greater density outside the historic downtown. Looking back, I see more wisdom in that decision than I probably appreciated at the time.

The city council did not declare preservation right and growth wrong, or vice versa. It found a way to move forward while honoring something important to both sides of the debate. The decision created opportunities for housing and development without immediately changing the heart of downtown.

Then something happened that no public meeting or staff report could have accomplished.

People gain experience with change

Over time, the community grew, housing needs evolved, and residents saw multi-family development become part of the community without erasing its identity. Eventually, downtown itself continued to redevelop with additional multi-family housing.

The values had not necessarily changed, but the community’s understanding of how those values could coexist had.

Technical Problems and Adaptive Challenges

In his 1994 book Leadership Without Easy Answers, author Ronald Heifetz distinguishes between technical problems, which can often be addressed through expertise and established solutions, and adaptive challenges, which require people to work through competing values, priorities, and change.

Our zoning debate of development in downtown contained both. Zoning was the technical question, but reconciling growth with community identity was the adaptive challenge.

That distinction changed how I think about conflict: More information alone may not resolve a disagreement rooted in values. Sometimes leadership means helping opposing groups understand what is important to each side and finding a reasonable next step that allows group participants to learn and adapt.

Compromise, in those circumstances, is not necessarily weak leadership. Sometimes it creates space for change to happen over time.

From Shared Values to Vision

We often treat organizational values as words adopted during a retreat and displayed on a wall or website. But values matter most when they help us make difficult choices.

When conflict occurs, leaders can ask:

  • What values are underneath the positions we are hearing?
  • What are people trying to protect?
  • Which values do we share despite our disagreement?
  • Can we find a path forward that respects those values?

Those questions do more than help navigate conflict. They can help people identify what matters most and clarify the kind of organization or community they want to become.

When shared values begin to shape vision

Shared values provide the foundation and vision describes the future we hope to create. Mission clarifies our purpose in pursuing that future, while strategy determines the choices we will make.

Those choices create focus, allowing limited community input, time, and money to be aligned around what matters most.

Conclusion

Twenty years ago, I probably thought my job was to help people understand the merits of the recommendation in front of them. Today, I would spend more time trying to understand what they valued and why.

Leaders cannot resolve every conflict of values by determining whose should win. Sometimes our most important contribution is helping people understand what they are trying to protect, discover what they share, and find a path forward.

The next time conflict surfaces, consider asking yourself: Am I arguing about people's positions or am I trying to understand the values prompting them?

In my next blog, I'll explore how shared values can become the foundation for crafting a meaningful, shared vision of the future.



MRSC is a private nonprofit organization serving local governments in Washington State. Eligible government agencies in Washington State may use our free, one-on-one Ask MRSC service to get answers to legal, policy, or financial questions.

Photo of Deborah Knight

About Deborah Knight

Deborah Knight is a retired city administrator with more than 30 years of local government experience, including serving as city administrator for the cities of Monroe, Stanwood, and Sultan. Throughout her career, she led organizations through periods of growth, fiscal challenges, organizational change, and major community initiatives.

Deborah is passionate about developing strong local government leaders and sharing the practical lessons she learned along the way. In retirement, she works in executive recruitment and writes and speaks about leadership, strategic planning, and turning strategy into results.

Deborah is writing as a guest author. The views expressed in guest columns represent the opinions of the author and do not necessarily reflect those of MRSC.

VIEW ALL POSTS BY DEBORAH KNIGHT